Money talks. It also makes people listen. And that’s the aim of a bill proposed by a Texas legislator.
Republican lawmaker, Wayne Smith, introduced a bill that would fine parents of children enrolled in public schools and leave them with a misdemeanor on their record for missing parent-teacher conferences. Ahh, if only this would pass, and I don’t think it will. Why? Because the people who would have to vote on it, many most likely parents, would never set themselves up to possibly be punished by such a measure.
I do wish that there was a way to go about holding parents accountable for their children’s education though. So many times blame is put on school districts and teachers, when children don’t pass state mandated tests or meet parents’ expectations. However, as I’ve said many times before, a child’s education doesn’t begin or suddenly end when school bells ring.
I now have two teenage students in my class who can’t read-one boy and one girl. The boy can’t even copy words or letters from the board, yet he knows how tag (gang graffiti). The girl can copy words from the board and her reading has improved thanks to a lot of one on one help, still she barely reads at the 2nd grade level. Yet, this girl knows the words to every song that comes on the radio. Her mother has continually blamed the school system for her daughter’s delays and academic failure. I agree that many have let this girl down by passing her along. However, at some point along the way, the girl’s mother had to have noticed that her daughter couldn’t read. Where was she? What responsibility does she take in this? None so far. It’s been everyone else’s fault.
I’ve had to call student’s parents or guardians to come and pick them up from school. One mother, answered the phone, still asleep (she didn’t work by the way), told me to call the girl’s grandmother and then hung up. Another girl’s grandmother, her primary guardian, gave me three different excuses from still under the influence of sleeping pills to having to go to the doctor to having to care for someone else, before telling me to call the girl’s aunt to come and get her.
Last week, a boy’s mother rescheduled the parent-teacher conference which was to allow her son to return to school. She didn’t reschedule just once. No, she rescheduled the parent-teacher conference each day last week. I was told on Friday afternoon that she was going to come in on Monday (tomorrow). Meanwhile the boy has been out of school for seven days. Being a new student, he had only attended school for two days prior to being sent home. We’ll see if he shows up tomorrow, but to be honest I’m not holding my breath.
On the day that her son was sent home, that same mother told me, and the assistant principal, that her son is a teenager and that she can’t make him do anything. She followed that with I don’t know what to do with him and then told us that she wanted to home school him but that the school district and court wouldn’t let her……..Pause a moment. Re-read that last sentence. What? If you can’t make him do anything, and you don’t know what do with him, the kid who stole a car and has engaged in other forms of criminal mischief, do you actually think he will listen to you as you try to homeschool him? But more importantly, you mean to tell me that even though this kid is living under your roof, eating up the food you paid for and you can’t make him do anything?!!? I listened to that mother make excuse after excuse for her son. She too didn’t wan’t to come and get him. At first, she said that she had be in court by 10 a.m. The mother is in the process of divorcing the boy’s father. However, the boy blew his mother’s cover by correcting her in front of the A.P. and me, stating, “No, you don’t have to be to court until 1p.m.
I think that Rep. Smith is on to something. I don’t know if his solution for holding parents more accountable is the way to go, but something definitely needs to be done.
Hats off and much applause to you parents who are actively involved in your child’s or children’s education. Not because you are doing something that is oh, so great. No, you’re doing what you’re supposed to do as a parent. I’m applauding you, because seemingly there are so few of you who are stepping up to the plate and truly parenting. I’m applauding you because you don’t just pass the buck and do a half assed job of it like so many that I and my colleagues have come across. I know it’s not easy. Believe me when I say that we (teachers) see you and we thank you.
Weigh in folks. Do you think the government or states should hold parents legally accountable for not committing themselves to actively participating in their child’s education?
Source:




February 5, 2007 at 6:43 pm |
Umm, I don’t think I would like what I would see if parents were FORCED to come to a conference. Nobody said they had to be polite, or cooperative, or sober, even. But the “state won’t let her” homeschool? Around here ANYONE can homeschool, and when I say homeschool, I mean “letting their kid wander around the neighborhood during workhours vandalizing public structures and trying to convince adults to buy them cigarettes.”
I also am nonplussed when parents say they can’t make their kids do anything. They’re just not willing to make their kids do anything.
February 5, 2007 at 8:31 pm |
I chuckled a bit when ready your comment. You’re right, parents who are forced to attend conferences would not be pretty. Afterall, after meeting many of my students’ parents, I walk away thinking Wow, it’s true. The apple really doesn’t fall far from the tree. I see where s/he gets it from. But I’m so tired of parents who are unwilling to show up and make time for their kids and then turn around and blame the system.
I was struck by a comment that a student of mine made a little over a year ago. While having a group conversation about open house and parents who visited during the day because they couldn’t make it that night, the girl stated, “I wish my mom would come to the school to check on me.” It reinforced what I already knew, which is that no matter how hard teenagers try to push adults away to assert their independence, they still like knowing that someone, namely mom or dad, cares and is willing to show up and be present for them.
As for the homeschooling thing, I’m not completely familiar with the homeschooling rules here, but I have heard that some states require that a person who wishes to home school is “qualified.” Now, I don’t know what qualified means, but it’s what I heard. Also, in the case of this kid, I see whay the courts and district won’t let her homeschool. This kid doesn’t have a good track record in her care as it is. If he won’t listen to her when he’s not at school, what makes her think that he’s going to listen to her when she takes on the role of his official teacher (for lack of a better term)?
I’m shaking my head now. I just wish there was a way to hold parents accountable as well. I find myself frustrated almost daily not with the kids but with the adults in their lives who are supposed to have their best interests at heart.
February 9, 2007 at 3:25 am |
No, I don’t agree with this stance. If parents are not intrinsically motivated re; their children’s shool work and careers, then a law won’t make it better.
February 18, 2007 at 7:23 pm |
We talked about this at my school. Can you imagine the paper work we would have to do to prove we had given them plenty of notice and chances to attend. On the other hand the threat might make some show up
February 19, 2007 at 12:01 pm |
Oh my, I never even considered the amount of paperwork that would go into maintaining or enforcing something like that! And goodness knows we don’t need anymore paperwork! Thanks for pointing that out.
Again, while Rep. Smith’s way may not be the best way to go about this, and trying to legally force parents to step up to the plate may not be the solution, I just wish there was some way to hold parents accountable just like everyone wants to hold teachers accountable.
February 19, 2007 at 12:02 pm |
Oh my, I never even considered the amount of paperwork that would go into maintaining or enforcing something like that! And goodness knows we don’t need anymore paperwork! Thanks for pointing that out. Againg, while Rep. Smith’s way may not be the best way to go about this, and trying to legally force parents to step up to the plate may not be the solution, I just wish there was some way to hold parents accountable just like everyone wants to hold teachers accountable.
February 24, 2007 at 2:11 pm |
For a lot of schools that use a parent-teacher conference scheduling program it would not be any paperwork at all. Take PTC Wizard ( http://www.ptcwizard.com )for example. It is an easy system to use and it let’s parents make their own schedules with teachers online. Teachers can check on their schedules and print out a copy before the conferences. That way, the teacher know who they are seeing BEFORE the parent sits down in front of them.
Parents love it because they can easily set up a meeting with the teacher at their convenience. Check out their website for more information http://www.ptcwizard.com.
February 14, 2009 at 6:31 am |
Please also fine the teachers who fail to notify the parent when a child’s grades are suffering. Every year I e-mail every teacher and ask them to please notify me if my son receives a “0″ on an assignment, or if my son’s grade falls below a “C”. Sure, they send home grade cards. But not knowing about a problem immediately greatly limits my ability to motivate change.