Well folks, it looks as if history may be on the verge of needlessly repeating itself.
If the Supreme Court and so called human rights organizations such as the Citizen’s Commission on Civil Rights get their way, the days of separate and certainly unequal education will return to the U.S. Do we really want to go there again?
My parents attended segregated schools in the South and while their experiences were not completely negative, they had to contend with blantant racism and weren’t treated fairly. My mother didn’t experience school integration until she was in high school. She graduated in 1970 for crying out loud! She once told me that the local ”black” school received the books that the “white” schools no longer wanted or the ones that were outdated. Because the white kids were aware that their books were going to be passed down to the black kids, they often tore out pages and wrote all kinds of racial slurs on the pages that remained. The white teachers weren’t any better. They often refused to send along the teacher’s guides to many of the books. Again, I ask, do we really want to go there?
If you have any doubts as to whether or not racism still exists in America, just check out the racism that is spewing forth on the AOL message boards and on this site regarding Tiger Woods, his wife Elin and their new baby. Contrary to what many would like to believe, racism is alive and well in the good ol’ U.S.A.
I understand that many want to move on and “just get over” America’s deep rooted past (and present) issues with race and the treatment of not only African Americans, but American Indian, Chinese Americans and Japanese Americans as well. I can’t even begin to count the number of times I heard white peers say, “well I’m not racist” or “I nor my family ever owned any slaves, so why should I apologize” and so forth. But the truth is, America as a whole, with whites being the ones who have held the real power in this country, have never opened up and tried to have a serious dialogue about race and inequality. Instead, laws have been passed in an effort to try to right past wrongs, but no one has ever truly sat down (e.g. G8 Summit style) and tried to come to an understanding.
As a person who attended predominantly white schools (high school was more diverse), who has white Godparents and has attended many sleepovers, parties, etc. with white friends, I can say that DIVERSITY DOES MATTER. They got to see that me and my family were in more ways than not, just like them. My mom was a college educated (she has a master’s degree) soccer mom, who carpooled to games and worked the concession stands, after working a full time job as a teacher too. My dad proudly served in the Air Force and Army Reserves, is a college grad as well, who taught his kids to respect all, work hard, save money, to never expect handouts and how to fish. Oh and he didn’t abandon us, even when he and my mother decided to part ways on fairly friendly terms.
The article mentioned that kids tend to become segregated through being pushed into special education or ESL/ESOL classes and yes this does happen. I’ve seen very bright kids placed in special education or lower level classes due to language barriers. This only serves to highlight the bigotry and prejudice that still exists in this nation and the education system. And I’ve even witnessed kids segregating themselves. Being a so called minority myself and after having talked to kids of various ethnicities, I can say that like simply tends to gravitate towards like…….or those that they feel comfortable with. But, one only needs to pay close attention to see that those same kids, who tend to gather with those with whom they have a lot in common, do play with and initiate conversation with kids outside of their own ethnic group quite often.
The bottom line is, if we keep kids of various races, ethnicities and social classes from coming into frequent contact with each other, we rob them of opportunity to dispel stereotypes, break down barriers and learn how to understand and get along with each other.
What do you all think? Are we heading in the wrong direction or what?
Image: Google Images AOL.com




July 1, 2007 at 2:02 am |
[...] Efron Link to Article tiger woods Have We Learned Anything From The Past? » Posted at Bright Minds [...]
July 1, 2007 at 7:52 am |
It is interesting that on one hand people say we are individuals and race doesn’t matter, but then say we need to decide which school children should go to based on race. This is my contribution to the race discussion you want to have. Are we individuals or members of a race? My vote is we are each unique individuals and the government should treat us that way. The ruling by the Supreme Court was a good one.
July 1, 2007 at 10:40 am |
My mom was from a military family and her father was stationed in Louisiana during her first few years of school. She still remembers how the African American kids she and her brothers played with around the neighborhood had to go to a different school than her.
Living in San Diego, I’m sad to say that racism is indeed alive and well. The street corner near the last place I lived was a pick-up spot for Hispanic day laborers, and the cement pylons near there was routinely painted with anti-immigrant graffiti.
July 1, 2007 at 12:23 pm |
Separate is inherently unequal.
That’s not the same as “separate is ok, if it wasn’t done on purpose”
July 1, 2007 at 3:47 pm |
Keith,
I want more than anything to be judged just on my abilities, skills, talents and just the QUALITIES that make me the “unique individual” that I am. However my life on this earth, in these United States thus far has shown me that I will be judged otherwise.
I was first called a nigger to my face in the 4th grade (and this was in the ’80’s my friend) and I’ve heard it on more occasions than I care to remember since then. See race most likely isn’t a factor for you because you’re white and have never been judged, mistreated, overlooked or had negative assumptions placed upon you because of the color of your skin.
Believe me, I want more than anything to be viewed as just another “unique individual” of the HUMAN race. However, many people (whether they acknowledge it or not) still look at race, skin color and for some reason and despise my brown skin without ever taking the time to get to know me………..the individual.
July 1, 2007 at 3:59 pm |
Perhaps if parents made concious efforts to explore their own biases and insist that their children grow up not only reading about other cultures (because the truth is not always accurately portrayed in a book or a magazine) or taking what they see portrayed on television and in movies for face value and actually educate or raise their kids around other races and ethnicities then there wouldn’t be a need for local and national government to step in and try to create diversity programs.
But, this is not the case.
July 3, 2007 at 1:55 pm |
Racism is everywhere. Denying it is the worst kind. We spent a staff development day looking at inequality in education. The day was really meant to point a finger at African Americans. It was awful. I see it every time a kid comes into the math office for placement testing. Some kids are given second chances. Others are put in the lowest level without a thought as to why they might have gotten something wrong. The worst racism I see in my school in ethnic and religious based. I’m sure a recent incident involving two of my students (I was not involved) would have been handled differently if they were not from the part of the world they are from.
July 4, 2007 at 7:52 am |
That’s real! Thanks for the reminder. Not that I need it with the NYC Public School system’s constant re-segregation, but yes thanks …
July 5, 2007 at 10:09 am |
I live in the South and my city (though it is large w/many types of people) is still segregated. I don’t like to harp on thefact that racism still exists, but it does. In my city, Whites live in certain sections and Blacks live in certain sections. In some places economics has to do with this, but even in poor communities they are segregated by race. Poor whites RARELY live in communities with African Americans. As African American infiltrate different areas of our city, White people move to the suburbs or outskirts of the city. This means that the children do not get to go “diverse” schools. Everyone is still attending school with “their own kind.” It still exists although now it isquiet, subtle and ECONOMIC.
Now, you mentioned that we don’t want to even discuss race as a society. It is true. Whites are scared–Plain and simple–they are scared. Example: I am teaching African American history at my school in the fall. I am absolute thrilled. Ecstatic! One of My BFFs who is White has mentioned several times that she is worried about me teaching this course. She is worried that I will hate her when it all over. How does learning the history and discussing the history of African Americans lead to me hating all Whites? (I’m somewhat offended b/c to me it is a statement that I’m not mature enough to handle history and put it in its appropriate context) That is not the goal of the course. The goal is to examine contributions of African Americans. To see the strong legacy we have . . .
As I review what I written, I appear to sound like rebel. I am not, just passionate. I support diversity. But with a ruling like this, how can diversity contiue. If America is like this before the Supreme Courts ruling, what happens after? I agree there will be regression in American society. I believe our “perfect” democracy is crumbling before our eyes. It is about more than forcing someone to attend a school they don’t want to. . . this ruling will affect the quality, funding and diversity of schools all across this country–Seperate will NOT be equal. And let me tell you seperate is going to set in, now.
July 6, 2007 at 9:18 am |
I agree with you wholeheartedly on this one. Attitudes like those expressed by posters here and even our Supreme Court justices worry me, the whole “Ignore race if you want racism to go away” theory. The biggest eye-opener for me in this exchange has been Beverly Daniel Tatum’s “Why Are All the Black Kids Sitting Together in the Cafeteria?” Your arguments reminded me of hers, which made perfect sense to me.
On the other hand, I do think that busing was an inadequate solution to the problem of real-estate-based inequality. The problem is much deeper than shipping a few kids to and from school daily, and I think the decision was made before foundations for more workable solutions could be laid. That worries me.